| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| C | Stephan Hatfield | Fayetteville State |
| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| SF | Curtis Fairchild | St. John Fisher |
| Position | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| PG | Jose Pina | Centre College |
| PG | Trenton Coates | Stanford |
| SG | Karel Mach | Gettysburg |
| SG | Chico Armendariz | Frostburg State |
| SF | Kendall Merritt | Lees-McRae |
| SF | Ömer Çelik | Southern Methodist |
| PF | Jim Xie | Fayetteville State |
| PF | Josh Golden | Hendrix |
| C | Vincent Hill | Marymount |
| C | Stephan Hatfield | Fayetteville State |
| X | Clint Green | Drexel |
| X | Harvey Preston | Haverford |
| X | James Rowland | Haverford |